Home Property Insurance Ought to Insurance coverage Appraisers Be Disqualified Earlier than or After the Appraisal Course of?

Ought to Insurance coverage Appraisers Be Disqualified Earlier than or After the Appraisal Course of?

Ought to Insurance coverage Appraisers Be Disqualified Earlier than or After the Appraisal Course of?


The P.L.A.N. Appraisal Certification Course begins at this time in Denver. One of many matters that will likely be mentioned is the {qualifications} of appraisers. What disqualifies an appraiser from an appraisal? The rule to recollect is that the principles appear to differ relying on the state of the insurance coverage appraisal.

When can an appraiser’s {qualifications} be challenged? Ought to it’s earlier than the appraisal award or after? That was a difficulty just lately determined in a Louisiana federal case.1 Listed below are the fundamental details recited by the choose:

Allied Belief filed this declaratory motion on June 28, 2023, looking for a declaration that (1) the Defendants take part within the appraisal course of contained within the insurance coverage coverage entered into between the events and that (2) the Defendants’ chosen appraiser, Nader Anthony Odeh, is disqualified from serving as appraiser for failing to satisfy the necessities of an neutral and disinterested appraiser. Allied Belief claims that an worker of Odeh, Jessica Campos, is the partner of the proprietor and operator of FC Residence Renovation, LLC, the identical agency that the Defendants obtained an estimate from. Accordingly, Allied Belief contends that Odeh has a battle of curiosity as a result of he has a ‘private and monetary curiosity within the consequence of the appraisal.’ Nevertheless, Allied Belief additional offers that the Defendants have agreed to take away FC Residence Renovation, LLC from performing any restore work on the Defendants’ property. Nonetheless, Allied Belief claims that ‘[n]othing would forestall FC Residence Renovations, LLC from performing the restore work on a later date.’

I imagine I’ve met the challenged policyholder’s appraiser and know him as Tony Odeh. In a Google search, I discovered The Nader Anthony Odeh Controversy: What You Want To Know. This Web piece said the next, which I used to be not conscious of:

Nader Anthony Odeh operates Boss Public Adjusting. As an skilled skilled in dealing with giant industrial and residential claims, he has been acknowledged as an knowledgeable in state and federal courts for dealing with insurance coverage claims and contracting issues.

Along with dealing with property disputes throughout the nation, Nader Odeh has additionally gained expertise in building legislation. This expertise has given him a firsthand understanding of how insurance coverage corporations deal with claims and what they anticipate claimants to submit a profitable attraction.

Anthony Odeh is a bulldog who ensures that insurance coverage corporations pay out full worth on denied or underpaid claims. Insurance coverage corporations have tried to cover from Mr. Odeh’s course of, however they know they may totally pay what they owe when he’s concerned.

Protection attorneys representing insurance coverage corporations like Mathew D. Monson of The Monson Regulation Agency LLC are attacking Mr. Odeh’s identify on-line in hopes of deterring folks combating a declare from amassing comprehensively their insurance coverage cash owed by their insurer. It’s essential to concentrate on the rumors and misinformation concerning the Nader Anthony Odeh controversy, as they don’t have any foundation in actuality.

I think about Mathew Monson might have one thing to say about this text. Monson is a really public, succesful, and robust advocate for his shoppers. All events have a proper to query whether or not an appraiser is certified below a selected state’s view of that concern. Are you able to think about if policyholders couldn’t problem a totally biased insurance coverage firm appraiser? It appears to me that insurers have that proper as nicely.

Nonetheless, Allied Belief’s Memorandum of Regulation famous the next, which additionally pointed to the reply of when Louisiana federal courts might entertain insurance coverage appraiser disqualification hearings:

In Ams. Ins. Co. v. Jarreau, each the insurer and the insured filed competing motions to compel appraisal, the plaintiff filed a movement to dismiss plaintiffs’ claims for legal professional charges, and the defendant filed a movement to disqualify the plaintiff’s appraiser. Deciding all 4 motions, the Honorable Decide Zainey dismissed the plaintiff’s declare for legal professional charges, compelled each events to take part in appraisal, and declined to disqualify the appraiser (Nader Odeh) at the moment, stating that the insurer might cross-examine the appraiser later and search to vacate the appraisal after an award was rendered.

The federal choose equally declined to entertain the declaratory judgment motion and agreed with the policyholder to dismiss the problem right now:

Federal courts are courts of restricted jurisdiction that may solely hear precise circumstances or controversies. Article III mandates that ‘[f]ederal courts don’t possess a roving fee to publicly opine on each authorized query.’  At this stage, Allied Belief successfully asks the Courtroom to offer an advisory opinion about potential conflicts of curiosity and potential problems with partiality and bias which haven’t but materialized and are completely speculative. Standing requires extra. As a result of standing implicates this Courtroom’s subject material jurisdiction, the Courtroom dismisses Allied Belief’s claims with out prejudice for lack of jurisdiction.2

I get requested the next query on a frequent foundation—“Chip, the insurance coverage firm employed an outcome-oriented and [words I am not going to write in this blog] appraiser. What can we do about it?”

The most effective reply in Louisiana and lots of states is to object to the appraiser as quickly as one is aware of of causes making the appraiser disqualified. For all , the opposite get together doesn’t know all of the details making the appraiser unqualified. If the opposite aspect refuses to take away the appraiser, search authorized counsel about what else to do and when to do one thing. The development in Louisiana appears to be to attend till the conclusion of the appraisal to problem an appraiser’s {qualifications}.

Larry Bache, Steve Badger, and yours really will likely be presenting on the P.L.A.N. appraisal course, as famous in P.L.A.N. Property Loss Appraiser & Umpire Certification Convention in Denver. In case you are not within the viewers and have a nagging query about appraisal, by no means hesitate to name or drop me a line. This weblog is stuffed with posts generated from such questions, which trigger me to write down for everyone.

Thought For The Day 

An American has not seen the USA till he has seen Mardi-Gras in New Orleans.

— Mark Twain

1 Allied Belief Ins. Co. v. Cosentino, No. 23-2251, 2024 WL 493301 (E.D. La. Feb. 8, 2024).

2 Id.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here